Social and Economic

The need for an effective and efficient transmission network to transfer green power generated in the south-western Victoria to the State power grid is recognised but it is important to consider the various environments and potential impacts that this transmission line project may have on local areas also.

Decreased Property Value

Land and Property Values will Plummet

The Moorabool Shire will suffer with ~60km of this transmission line.  It appears that the preferred siting of these transmission towers will be north of the Western Freeway from Ballarat to Bacchus Marsh.  In the Bacchus Marsh area, the towers would likely be placed along the northern edge of Darley between Darley and the Wombat State Forest / Lerderderg State Park.

If these 85m high, 500kV high voltage transmission towers and lines are in the field of view from properties, it will drastically affect the environment and landscape views, forever.  As a result, it will also directly affect local land and property values.  These impacts cannot be mitigated later.

Diminished regional appeal and negative economic impact

Diminished Regional Appeal and Negative Economic Impact

These massive towers will destroy the widely held view of the region as being a clean, green, healthy, semi-rural lifestyle, surrounded by pleasant landscapes and natural assets.  Devaluing the ‘appeal’ of the region will have flow-on effects and will impact on the number of visitors to the region (currently >500,000 per year) and also retard the projected growth-rate of this, ‘significant Growth-Corridor’, as identified in both the Plan Melbourne and Central Highlands Regional Growth Plans.

As the land values for the area decline and the population growth expectations reduce, so will future investment, amenities, facilities and consequently, quality of the lifestyle of residents, property owners and businesses.

Residents living in the Moorabool Shire do so because they want to be near Melbourne while still living a lifestyle surrounded by a semi-rural atmosphere and its associated natural landscapes.  Everyone loves our smaller towns with their serene country charms, and we need to protect these from the impacts of these imposing infrastructures.

Regional Tourism

Regional Tourism

Landscapes are significant to different people for different reasons. The reasons vary from bring admired for their scenic beauty, to the historic value, recreation, mental health, the environmental qualities, and/or the value to the regional economy and other less tangible values associated with the place, such as memories or associations.

The Moorabool Shire contains a number of environmental and natural assets both of National, State and local significance. This includes the Long Forest Nature Conservation Reserve, Brisbane Ranges National Park, Lerderderg State Park, Werribee Gorge State Park, and the Wombat State Forest all of which are key assets within the Shire and attract an estimated visitation of approximately 550,000 people per year across all sites.

The community is concerned of the amenity impacts the transmission lines will have on these natural landscapes and the negative impact that will have on the State and Regionally significant landscapes and views that were identified in the South West Landscape Assessment Study (Planisphere, 2012).

The South West Landscape Assessment Study Describes the Lerderderg as…

This landscape is iconic as a wild and rugged place within the context of the broader regional landscape, in close proximity to Melbourne.

The distinctive rock formations and contrast in vegetation patterns of the gorge is iconic and scarce within the local context.

The composition of views and landscape elements within the Park are iconic in the context of the immediate location. Panoramic views of the broader landscape from Mount Blackwood are exceptional.

Aesthetics, Livability and Wellbeing

Aesthetic benefit to tourism, liveability, and wellbeing: These proposed towers are already having profound mental health and physiological impacts to those who may be impacted. These towers and cables are eyesores and to suggest placing them in the vicinity shows scant regard for the residents, the environment and tourists who travel to enjoy the area. Many residents have chosen a peaceful, country lifestyle and this project is ripping it all away and causing mental anguish in many of us.

Contrary to Established Practices

It is noted that the northern area of Darley is currently supplied mostly by underground power. It would be ludicrous to negate these fire-risk abatement measures by installing 500kV overhead power lines on 85m towers in the area between Darley and Lerderderg State Park, Wombat State Forrest, Werribee Gorge State Park and Long Forest Conservation Reserve, as it appears currently, to be the plan.

Placing overhead high voltage power lines in areas north of the Western Highway between Ballarat and Bacchus Marsh/Darley would increase the risk of fire, with potential for significant impact on these parks, landscape assets, flora and fauna, and of course residences and thousands of visitors to this major Victorian growth corridor. With the prevailing summer wind conditions, any fires in these forested areas and/or the effects of associated ember attack, would directly threaten the Darley northern-boundary homes and properties on the hills to the south towards Swans Road and the rest of Darley.

Major Impacts

Major Impacts

The importance of major infrastructure projects with state-wide benefits, is recognised and supported by the communities, but it is important to ensure that these benefits are not delivered at the expense of significant impacts on select communities along its path.

It is important to consider the local community’s concerns of the potential impacts that this project will have on their lifestyle and welfare.

The International Council on Large Electrical Systems (CIGRÉ) compared the greatest concerns of international communities on overhead power lines. Depreciation of land values was of major concern, surpassed only by visual and potential health impacts. Depreciation of land values is a significant impact on communities and deserves to be acknowledged and mitigated where possible.

Underground transmission cabling minimizes land depreciation impacts, while reliably and economically delivering power, satisfying the expectations of all communities concerned.

Residents living in the Moorabool Shire do so because they want to be near Melbourne while still living a lifestyle surrounded by a semi-rural atmosphere and its associated natural landscapes.  Everyone loves our smaller towns with their serene country charms, and we need to protect these from the impacts of these imposing infrastructures.

Moorabool Planning Scheme

Moorabool Council’s Municipal Strategic Statement (MSS) objectives are to protect significant landscapes and vistas, and the natural features of the area including biodiversity.  The natural landscape and environmental assets of Bacchus Marsh are to be respected.

The natural landscapes of Bacchus Marsh District are diverse and complex, defined by their valleys, ridgelines, plateaus and escarpments.

The Environmental Significance Overlay (ESO2) is applied to the Lerderderg River and land 100m either side of the River to protect waterways that supply catchments for urban and rural development.

Bacchus Marsh Urban Growth Framework, produced by the Victorian Planning Authority, indicates a 500m buffer to sensitive uses in the corridor between Darley residential and the Lerderderg State Park.

Urban Growth Framework

Share this post